soup

Perfect for a cold winter’s day.

Before anything hits the shop’s chalkboard menus, the owners and select patrons savor 10 of the best recipes and rank their favorites.

A counter with literature-themed offerings includes warming renditions of red-pepper curry; broccoli cheddar; Tuscan white bean with steamed kale and potatoes; and a thick, sweet tomato bisque.

Including the Lemon Souffle Pancakes worth road-tripping down to New Albany for.

Scott Wise, Lindy Brown, Valerie Vanderpool, Carrie Abbott, and more weigh in on their preferences and favorites.